CATEGORY

1

2

3

4

Group Presentation

An all-around poor presentation

A presentation lacking organization and in need of improvement

A well-designed and organized presentation. Presentation has some minor areas for improvement

A well-designed, creative, and organized presentation. An all-around excellent presentation

Required Elements

Presentation failed to address several of the required elements

Presentation did not contain all of the required elements

Presentation adequately includes and addresses the required elements

Presentation thoroughly includes and fully addresses the required elements

Individual Roles

Individual fails to address required elements

Individual not in character; required elements are not sufficiently addressed

Individual usually in character; adequately addresses the required elements

Individual always in character; deeply and passionately addresses the required elements

Written Script  

Individual's responses lack understanding and application of content

Individual's responses show a limited understanding and application of content; inappropriate responses for the role  of the mystery

Individual's responses are based on a sufficient understanding and application of content; responses appropriate for the role of the mystery

Individual's responses are based on a thorough understanding and application of content; responses are fully appropriate for the role of the mystery